Noté 3 sur 5 étoiles

When redirecting an email for example to a Google recipient the whole content of the mail will be destroyed.

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.9.6). 

This is not the place to report errors. Please go to the support site. That being said: there is a reported problem about some messages not being redirected in Thunderbird 60.*, maybe that's also the problem you are experiencing? Can you try out the beta version from github to see if it solves your problem?
https://github.com/mailredirect/mailredirect/releases/tag/mailredirect-0-9-7b1

Noté 5 sur 5 étoiles

Installé sur Macbook, tous les mails redirigés sont reçu comme spam; Sur Windows 10, les mêmes mails sont reçu sans problèmes. Y-a-t-il un réglage à faire ?

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.9.6). 

There's probably a difference in the junk mail control settings between the Macbook and Windows 10.
Check under Tools > Account Settings > [account] > Junk Settings if all settings are the same.
Even if the settings are the same, behavior can still be different, e.g. when you have different training data for adaptive junk mail controls on the two computers or when your personal address books are different.

Noté 5 sur 5 étoiles

I've been this extension for years, and always does its job!

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.9.5).  Cet utilisateur a 3 critiques précédentes de ce module.

Noté 5 sur 5 étoiles

Previous version worked fine, this one makes the Redirect button in the Mail Redirect window greyed out and unavailable when I begin to type whatever in the Resend-To field.

Edit:
New version 0.9.6a1 is working now as fine as previously! Thanks a lot Onno!

BTW, is it possible to fill Resend-From field with the message's Delivered-To account by default, not the first account from Thunderbird's list?

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.9.5). 

This was caused by a function that got removed in Thunderbird 57.0a1 and was replaced by another function in Thunderbird 59.0a1.

nsIScriptableDateFormat was removed and first replaced with Intl.createDateTimeFormat and later with Intl.DateTimeFormat.

I've uploaded a new version to the development channel of AMO that solves this problem for beta users. Please go to AMO, scroll all the way to the bottom and click View classic desktop site, switch to Other Applications > Thunderbird on the top right, select/search Mail Redirect and scroll down again to open the Development Channel section and download version 0.9.6a1 and install it to your Thunderbird 57.0b* or 58.0b*.

P.S. I try to determine to which account the original messages was sent and use that account as the default from address. If that doesn't work, please file a ticket at https://sourceforge.net/p/mailredirect/tickets/

Noté 2 sur 5 étoiles

Mail server gives an error:
5.7.0 Failed to authorize the sender 1517494895-2z6Ljv0H5M-LZjiFfek 1517494895-cnw9fN8Bpu-LVqeibT9
Check the message and try again (translate from Russian).

Thunderbird Portable 38.7.1

What is it?

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.9.5). 

Hi, the error message you get is a server error. You have to check with your mail provider for the exact error. There can be many reasons for this error, but probably you've sent too many messages in a short period of time and you have to wait a bit to be able to send messages again. You can try to prevent this from happening, by setting the number of concurrent SMTP-connections to a lower value, for instance to 1 in Mail Redirect's Options.

Noté 5 sur 5 étoiles

works ok

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.9.2). 

Noté 5 sur 5 étoiles

Just a pity that it's not possible to use it within filters !

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.9.1). 

I'm sorry, but adding this takes a lot of work, which I don't have at the moment. In the meantime, you can use the add-on RedirectFilter, which is also available from amo…

Noté 5 sur 5 étoiles

Being an admin, I need to redirect wrongly addressed emails very often. This tool is perfect!

Als Admin muss ich sehr häufig fehlgeleitete Emails umleiten - Hiermit ein Kinderspiel!

Still working with TB 52.x on Win10pro64.

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.9.1). 

Noté 4 sur 5 étoiles

Очень хорошее дополнение к Thunderbird.
Единственное чего бы хотелось, это возможности сохранять перенаправленные письма в произвольную (указанную пользователем) папку, а не только в папку "отправленные".

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.9.1). 

Thank you for your review and your suggestion to be able to specify a special Resent folder. It looks like a nice feature to me.

Noté 2 sur 5 étoiles

Based on the most recent review and the developer's response, the issue with the blank "Preview" pane is attributed to another Add-on. However, I do not have the other addon installed (Reply Monitor).


Good but I got trouble Rated 3 out of 5 stars

by canaglia.putiferio on September 13, 2016 · permalink · translate

I'm trying your TB Add-on but I got problem; after I instelled it hide the preview message tool bar.. so now I can't see button for quick reply and so on..
Can you help me !?

Report this review

Conflict with Reply Monitor add-on

by Onno Ekker (Developer) on September 14, 2016 · permalink · translate

This seems to be caused by a conflict between Mail Redirect and Reply Monitor add-on. I'll try to find out if it can be fixed on my side, or better in Reply Monitor.

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.8.7). 

Hi ILMostro7,
I'm sorry to hear Mail Redirect also doesn't work for you. Can you please report the problem via the support website link or via e-mail? There I have room to ask more questions and get more info to see what's wrong in your case.
Thanks in advance,
Onno

Noté 3 sur 5 étoiles

I'm trying your TB Add-on but I got problem; after I instelled it hide the preview message tool bar.. so now I can't see button for quick reply and so on..
Can you help me !?

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.8.7). 

This seems to be caused by a conflict between Mail Redirect and Reply Monitor add-on. I'll try to find out if it can be fixed on my side, or better in Reply Monitor.

Noté 3 sur 5 étoiles

Manually redirects fine...but I was looking to be able to set up a filter that would automatically redirect messages meeting certain criteria. There is no "redirect" option in the filters menu of choices (I can only "forward".)

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.8.7). 

Hi, this is some functionality that is on my radar, but it's not easy to implement and I haven't got the time to really dive into it. Adding filter action isn't the hard part, but sending in the background is…

Noté 5 sur 5 étoiles

Расширение Mail Redirect 0,8,7 не работает при пересылке с ящика mail.ru, с gmail.com все работает отлично.
mail.ru отвечает ошибкой Ошибка отправления почты. Почтовый сервер ответил: Message was not accepted -- it contains invalid headers. More specially, 'From:' header must match user you are sending mail from. See http://help.mail.ru/mail-help/mailer/popsmtp for details.. Проверьте сообщение и попробуйте снова.
Что можно сделать?
А Версия Mail Redirect 0.8.8.1а тоже не работает любая пересылка. Ошибка " не является адресом электронной почты, так как он написан не в форме пользователь@сервер. Вы должны исправить его перед отправкой сообщения."

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.8.7). 

Hi,
Please check your error log in version 0.8.8a1 and send relevant information to me. See http://mailredirect.sourceforge.net/support.html for more help.

Noté 5 sur 5 étoiles

I tried it on Earlybird 47.0a2 (2016-03-22)
not working.
I just run ahead the schedule. Thanx anyway! Such a tiny thing, but so necessary!!!

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.8.7). 

Hi, thank you for your review! I've uploaded Mail Redirect 0.8.8a1 which fixes this issue. Since you're ahead of schedule I guess you don't mind too much running a alpha version… Go to Mail Redirect on addons.mozilla.org and click on Development Channel on the bottom of the page to download the new release.

Version 0.8.8a1 contained an error for Thunderbird 38 and lower, so I released 0.8.8a2…

Noté 5 sur 5 étoiles

A standard feature that should have been present in Thunderbird. Luckily, this add-on comes to the rescue, and does the job well. I also like the fact that it does not mess around with the mail, and is a true "redirect".

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.8.7). 

Noté 5 sur 5 étoiles

Very useful for me. Does exactly what it should. Thank you!

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.8.7). 

Noté 3 sur 5 étoiles

For years now this add-on has used "bounce" in the description, as in "Allow to redirect (a.k.a. "bounce") mail messages to other recipients." "Bouncing" has a very clear meaning in English tech circles when discussing email. It means bouncing back to the original sender.

This add-on doesn't do that, and it's very confusing for people searching for an add-on that does bounce. You can look at the previous reviews and find others that have installed this add-on, only to be disappointed that it doesn't do what they think it should do based on the description.

The developer needs to change the description to remove the word "bounce" completely and save us all a lot of time and confusion.

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.8.7). 

"bounce" was also used in mutt mail client. That's why, years ago, I put this term in the description.
Now mutt use "remail" rather than bounce. We will change the description in the next update. Thanks for your feedback!

Noté 5 sur 5 étoiles

Thanks, this is a much needed Add-On; providing a feature that should been in the stock T'Bird issue.

One small detail in need of attention is that no redirect option appears in the 'Perform These Actions' drop down in the 'Filter Rules' dialogue

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.8.5). 

Noté 5 sur 5 étoiles

Great Addon!!! Would be perfect if supports Office 365 accounts.
:-(

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.8.5). 

Noté 2 sur 5 étoiles

I mostly wish to redirect (bounce) an email to the sender, but the senders email address does not appear in the box, I have to insert it myself, a message that the mail was not required could also be added.

Cette critique concerne une version précédente du module (0.8.5). 

Sorry, but this extension is not for this purpose. To bounce back letting the sender think the address is unknown, would require complete other logic (and doesn't have much use for spammers anyway) and changing the message by saying the mail was not required is also not according to the specs of redirecting. You should use a normal reply message for that.