评分3星,满分5星

Coming from Outlook, notes that are connected to individual emails are a must for productivity. In outlook it is also accomplished through a paid add-on which is not without issues but my experience is that the entire outlook experience is bugged. Qnote is the reason for making the move as my daily email client. I was ready to donate today to the Dev but I was adjusting the note position and testing out the Toggle (Alt-Q) when the email I was working with suddenly and irrevocably disappeared. Alt-Q worked smoothly a dozen times and then poof - gone. I tried for over an hour to find it. Yes, I looked in Spam, Trash, Draft and even my Deleted Folder. I searched the Qnote storage folder in Explorer but could not read the files. I batch renamed the list of files to *.txt and was able to read them however not one belonged to the deleted email. I'm only trying to warn people because this seems to be a very serious bug and why I am only rating Qnote a 3 for now. I even checked for the message on my server where it should remain untouched as my settings to imap in order to leave files on the server when deleting.

评分5星,满分5星

Warning - Don't update to TB 125 as it will auto-disable this extension.

If you are surprised by this, you can patch the extension to work again (own risk).

1. Rename *.xpi file to *.zip and unzip using 7zip

2. Edit manifest.json file and set strict_max_version": "125.*" or whatever Version you have to.

3. Save manifest.json

4. Create an new Zip archive containing all files from the old archive but with the updated manifest file using 7zip.

5. Rename zip file to xpi file and manually install in TB.

If you get an error, you may have included path/folder into your zip file. Make sure the content looks the same as in the original file.

TESTED with TB 125 but as I said: Your risk.

...sooo sad, the extension isn't maintained any more.

评分1星,满分5星

Unfortunately, it only works with restrictions and probably only for users who only manage one or two mail accounts with very few emails. Because if there are (significantly) more accounts and emails, QNote needs up to 45 seconds until the corresponding marking for an email appears if you have marked the corresponding email with the mouse.
Independent of this and probably related to the first problem is the fact that you cannot tell from a list of emails which email has a note.
Actually, a note is supposed to counteract human forgetfulness. But if I don't remember which email I left a note in and whether I left it at all, that's of very little use to me...

Reaction to answer 1:
Dear Martin,
I have no reason to complain. After all, you are providing it for free. Therefore, my text above should be seen as constructive criticism.
However, I see it from the user's perspective without any significant programming knowledge. For me as a user it is not clear why something does not work as expected. All I can say is that this is the case (for me).
However, I now use a similar product from a competitor. Although this cannot create an extra column due to the restrictions in TB115.x, But it does offer the option of setting a keyword and colored marking in parallel when creating a note so that I see a eMail with a note on the 1st view in a bunch of hundreds.
But what is much more important is that this competitor's product displays this note _immediately_ and without any noticeable delay when I click on an email with a note.

Just don't use it with TB115. TB115 introduced breaking API changes (yet again).

评分5星,满分5星

Super extension qui m'a permis de retrouver mes notes XNote++ (non compatible TB115*).
J'espère que la recherche rapide dans les notes reviendra sur de futures versions...

评分5星,满分5星

5 stars but I hope che column "qnote" will return soon as well the capability to search messages by note using quicksearch

评分4星,满分5星

As soon as there is a separate column available in the mail list, i will add the fifth star

评分5星,满分5星

a pity however with this 115.3.1 (and unfortunately not the only problem with this version...

Thanks!

Indeed. I already downgraded back to 102.

评分5星,满分5星

Excellent. However, the date and time formatting rules do not all work. For ex: h does not show 12 hour format with leading zeros; it shows "h" ... a shows as "a" not lowercase am or pm etc. (more do not work). A seemingly small annoyance for some; for others it is important.

I submitted an issue on Github.

Thanks for review. These letters are not implemented (yet) as shown in settings.

评分5星,满分5星

Love this addon very practical and help a lot with my work emails. The only thing i noticed with thunderbird update 115.3.1 (64-bit) when i filtered or searched messages i had the option to select qnote so it can search the notes as well whereas now i dont have that option no more

评分5星,满分5星

great, is it possible to make sync notes on gmail imap accounts? i will pay a lot for that! :)

Hi! Please send details and full requirement list to [email protected] and I will see what can be done.

评分4星,满分5星

Great plugin but unfortunately it stopped working with TB Supernova 115.1.1

Thanks for review! It does work but not all features are available in v115. You can put blame on TB for removing bunch of stuff in v115. Here is more information:

https://github.com/mlazdans/qnote/issues/45#issuecomment-1660881810

评分4星,满分5星

A very nice addition but I have one remark about refreshing the added note icon in the email list. We use three computers and notes are stored on a network drive. If I add a note on one computer, only after closing and opening thunderbird on the other computer I see the added note icon in the email list. In the XNote add-on, the icons of added notes refresh immediately in the email list on all computers (no need to close and reopen thunderbird).

这个评论是针对附加组件的一个早期版本的(0.12.2)。 

评分5星,满分5星

great

这个评论是针对附加组件的一个早期版本的(0.12.2)。 

评分5星,满分5星

Wow I love this thing ! It's almost exciting!
You even thought of export for safety. You're a lord!
I really wish Windows had a similar thing for folders.

这个评论是针对附加组件的一个早期版本的(0.12.2)。 

评分5星,满分5星

Great addon. I would love to have the notes stored as emal headers on the IMAP server so that several people mounting the mailbox share the notes (use case : support team, avoiding simultaneous access).
It did crash TB 102.7.1 until I removed the storage folder so it got started fresh.

这个评论是针对附加组件的一个早期版本的(0.12.2)。 

Please use github for issue reporting.

评分5星,满分5星

After changes in manifest.json ("strict_max_version": "106.*") working with TB 105.*
Thank YOU!

这个评论是针对附加组件的一个早期版本的(0.11.2)。 

评分5星,满分5星

QNOTE++ has been working perfectly fine for me in the past. Unfortunately with TB 102 Beta 1 it's broken. Could you please make it functional again? Contribution is on its way. Thank you

这个评论是针对附加组件的一个早期版本的(0.11.1)。 

Better way to put this is not QNote is broken, but rather they broke extensions API (again) :/

P.S.
Thanks for donation!

评分5星,满分5星

Nice, simple, helpful.

这个评论是针对附加组件的一个早期版本的(0.10.4)。 

评分4星,满分5星

Notes are not "shareable" across IMAP, correct? It would be really SUPER if I could place notes on a message that would be viewable by other users on the same IMAP account.

But great product! Love it!

这个评论是针对附加组件的一个早期版本的(0.10.4)。 

This is out of QNote use case. You can always share messages via shared folder. Adding IMAP manipulations would bloat up code base, hard to debug, introduce nasty bugs due various IMAP implementations floating around, etc.

评分4星,满分5星

It is great, but does not work well with Nostalgy++ extension. I cannot write into the floating panel (nothing happens), but Nostalgy grabs the keystrokes. If I change it to "Popup window", it works well, but this popup always pops up in the center of the screen and positioning does not work.

这个评论是针对附加组件的一个早期版本的(0.10.4)。 

You can bump Nostalgy++ author to apply a fix:
https://github.com/opto/nostalgy-xpi/issues/128#issuecomment-1100380599